Texans, the subject line does not do justice. To put it bluntly, we got our butts kicked. It’s my duty to haul out the sordid history and attempt to assess some blame.
If by now you are still unaware, the matter is this: Among some otherwise sensible state governments there is a high-profile competition to show the most ridiculous face to the rest of the world. And Texas just got aced out of number one. It happened this way:
Historically The Great State of Texas has had a nice lock on the title, challenged most notably when Tennessee passed the Butler Act in 1924 and then prosecuted John T. Scopes for teaching evolution in a public school in Dayton. Texas quickly got back in the game. Edward J. Larson has an excellent book on the history of this dubious competition, and you can follow the sordid details there. See the references.
Shortly after the Scopes trial Texas Governor Miriam Ferguson directed the Texas Textbook Commission to delete “evolution from all public school texts.” Since then Texas has never been completely out of the game.
There was a close call in 1995 when parents in the Plano Independent School District rose up against attempts to introduce the creationist Of Pandas and People into the curriculum. Apparently these parents were unaware that we are engaged in a desperate competition over the low road to education. As a result, parents in Plano blew the point and set Texas back some distance by rising up and defeating the creationist strategy.
More recently Texas recovered all lost ground and established itself in first (and lowest) place by appointing a number of blatant creationists on its State Board of Education. The antics of Board president Don McLeroy, a former dentist turned educational reformer, helped to gain for Texas a new low and also the competitive front tier. Allow me to illustrate the beauty of the Texas game plan.
Typical of creationists world-wide, McLeroy loved to use out of context quotes to make his case, and a Web site features some of his notable ventures into this never world. Here is one.
McLeroy: “New Zealand’s ‘living dinousaur’ – the Tuatara – is surprisingly the fastest evolving animal. It is unchanged in 200 million years.” This is quoted from Science Daily, March 23, 2008.
What Science Daily said was this:
New Zealand's 'Living Dinosaur' – The Tuatara – Is Surprisingly The Fastest Evolving Animal
…In a study of New Zealand's "living dinosaur" the tuatara, evolutionary biologist, and ancient DNA expert, Professor David Lambert and his team from the Allan Wilson Centre for Molecular Ecology and Evolution recovered DNA sequences from the bones of ancient tuatara, which are up to 8000 years old. They found that, although tuatara have remained largely physically unchanged over very long periods of evolution, they are evolving – at a DNA level – faster than any other animal yet examined.
…"Of course we would have expected that the tuatara, which does everything slowly – they grow slowly, reproduce slowly and have a very slow metabolism – would have evolved slowly. In fact, at the DNA level, they evolve extremely quickly, which supports a hypothesis proposed by the evolutionary biologist Allan Wilson, who suggested that the rate of molecular evolution was uncoupled from the rate of morphological evolution."
…The tuatara, Sphendon punctatus, is found only in New Zealand and is the only surviving member of a distinct reptilian order Sphehodontia that lived alongside early dinosaurs and separated from other reptiles 200 million years ago in the Upper Triassic period.
One would have thought that maintaining our lead to the bottom would involve keeping Dr. McLeroy in his place on the Board. You would have been right in the first respect, but you would be wrong if you thought the Texas Senate was suited up for the game. Possibly state politicians got tired of answering embarrassing questions and of seeing national and world publications mention our state with the hint of a sneer. In any event, Governor Rick Perry reappointed McLeroy as chairman of the Board (way to go, Guv), but the Senate, dominated by Perry’s own party, rejected the nomination. Sic transit Gloria.
Worse yet, the Senate rejected Perry’s nomination of notorious creationist Gail Lowe to replace McLeroy as chairman. What can you do with a government like this?
That was not the final blow, however. Texas had one final hope for maintaining its grip on the short end of the stick. A few years back the Louisiana Legislature enacted, and Governor Jindal signed into law the “Louisiana Science Education Act.” The title was a little play on words, because the real purpose was “to create and foster an environment within public elementary and secondary schools that promotes critical thinking skills, logical analysis, and open and objective discussion of scientific theories being studied including, but not limited to, evolution, the origins of life, global warming, and human cloning.” The law was transparently aimed at protecting teachers who stepped outside the law and the science curriculum. The law givers, I am sure, had in mind giving cover to those who promoted politically favorable alternatives to mainstream science.
If you were the quarterback for Texas public education, you would have been watching with a dry mouth as the clock ran out the game slipped away. But there was still hope in Mudville.
As we reported last month, hope for Texas came from the good citizens of Louisiana. What were they thinking?
Continuing support for Louisiana repeal effortAdding their support for the effort to repeal Louisiana's antievolution law are the New Orleans City Council and the American Association for the Advancement of Science. Senate Bill 70, would, if enacted, repeal Louisiana Revised Statutes 17:285.1, which implemented the so-called Louisiana Science Education Act, passed and enacted in 2008. The American Institute for Biological Sciences, the American Society for Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, the American Society for Cell Biology, the Louisiana Association of Biology Educators, the Louisiana Science Teachers Association, the National Association of Biology Teachers, and the Society for the Study of Evolution together with the Society of Systematic Biologists and the American Society of Naturalists, as well as forty-three Nobel laureates, have already endorsed SB 70.
Texas appeared to have the low rung firmly within its grip. Then, disaster. The National Center for Science Education has the bad news:
Repeal bill officially deadJune 24th, 2011…
When the Louisiana state legislature adjourned on June 23, 2011, Senate Bill 70 (PDF) — which would have repealed the antievolution law in effect in the state since 2008 — died in committee. SB 70 was introduced by Karen Carter Peterson (D-District 5), but the driving force behind the repeal effort was Baton Rouge high school senior Zack Kopplin, working with the Louisiana Coalition for Science. The bill swiftly won the support of scientists and educators throughout the state and across the nation, including the American Association for the Advancement of Science, the National Association of Biology Teachers, the Louisiana Association of Biology Educators, the American Institute for Biological Sciences, and no fewer than forty-three Nobel laureates. On May 26, 2011, however, the Louisiana Senate Education Committee voted 5-1 to shelve the bill. "With the law intact," as the Christian Science Monitor (June 2, 2011) commented, "Louisiana is the state that has gone the furthest in approving legislation that opens the door to allowing alternatives to science taught in its schools." But Kopplin, in a statement quoted by the Louisiana Coalition for Science, vowed, "we'll come back with an even stronger repeal next session." (emphasis added)
GOAL!!!
The game is gone. Texas, now you know how it feels to be number two.